In regards to his lack of skill as in emcee:
LIke what? Breath control? Cadence? Use of alliteration and unique rhyme patterns? Proven freestyle ability? If there is anything that Em does have going for him, it is his all around technical emcee skills.
I seriously think that Eminem will always have an uphill battle. Some people love him just because he's white and buy into the image and the hype rather than the actual music. Some people hate him for the same exact reason. Give respect where respect is due. There is no denying his strengths as a battle emcee, as a technically sound emcee, and as a skilled emcee. If you don't agree with the content, then that's fine. If you don't like his image, I can respect that. But when it comes down to his overall skill as an emcee, there is no denying that.
Eminem is like the Biggies and the 2Pacs of the world because they crossed over HEAVILY over to the typically non-Hip Hop crowd. People somehow forget how Biggie put out one radio friendly song after another to cater to non-Hip Hop fans for the sole intent of going X times platinum. Jay-Z gets more love in suburban America than anyone not named Eminem. What do you think they're playing at a 7th grade sock hop in the middle of Montana. I dont' know either, but I'll bet that they played "In The Club" 3 or 4 times so all the little kids could try to Harlem Shake or C-Walk to it (probably looking like a room full of epileptics). So look how easy it was for 50 to cross over.
My point is that you can hate him for crossing over. You can hate him for getting more love from White America. But you can't deny the fact that the "greats" that came before them are responsible for someone like Eminem. Em didn't write the blueprint of how to be successful in Hip Hop. It was there already. Biggie went multi-platinum why? Because he crossed over. Jay-Z went multi-platinum why? Becase he crossed over. So if Em getting love from White America is somewhat unfair "because he's already White", why have all the past greats done the same exact thing?
No one hated Eminem until he became rich. When he was broke, we all saw him as a talented emcee who was unique and funny. No one cared that he was white. He was looked at for his skill, not his appearance. It's funny how people can start to nitpick once someone gets rich.
Don't get it twisted. Em isn't exactly my favorite emcee in the world. I have known of Em since '97, just after he competed at Scribble Jam. I see him for what he is as an emcee, not for his image, his hype or anything else.
In regards to the mentioning of 2Pac as a "global icon" similar to Elvis, and Eminem as "just another rapper"..
Funny that you'd bring up Elvis.
More parallels can be drawn from the career and popularity of Elvin and EMINEM than between Pac and Elvis. Eminem and Elvis both are white men doing what is considered "black" music and doing it successfuly. Before Elvis came out and eventually being the "King Of Rock N' Roll", Rock N' Roll was predominantly considered "black music".
Sound a little familliar?
As far as "Em not being on that level", you're sadly mistaken. Eminem is the most popular,not the greatest nor the best, but the most popular rapper in the world while Hip Hop music is an an all-time high level of worldwide popularity. In short, he is sitting on top of the Rap mountain that is bigger than it has ever been as far as worldwide popularity.
"Not on that level?" Hip Hop is international folks. We got b-boys in Korea, Graf writers in Paris and dj's from the Philippines competing at the DMC world championships. Eminem is currently the most talked about emcee on the planet. Period.
Who's the greatest emcee? Who knows? Hip Hop is only a little more than 29 year's old and we've come a long way since DJ Kool Herc threw that first party at 1520 Sedgewick Ave. in the Bronx. I think the "G.O.A.T." will keep getting trumped as Hip Hop continues to grow. It'll be different every 5 years because Hip Hop will continue to grow and innovate. Stop trying to make yourselves feel better about what you listen to by saying "X Emcee is the best". What's the point? Look at the bigger picture for once.